Plenty of horror gets watched on Halloween. Far less of it actually takes place on Halloween. John Carpenter's Halloween is the reason the date became a setting: Michael Myers kills his sister on Halloween night in 1963 and comes home fifteen years later to the day, while Haddonfield's babysitters watch horror movies and a man in a blank mask passes for part of the holiday. Carpenter wrote it with Debra Hill, scored it himself on a synthesizer, and gave Jamie Lee Curtis her first film role. Every movie below inherits something from that night, above all the idea that on October 31 a stranger in a mask raises no alarm at all.
The rule here is strict: every film happens on October 31 or in the days running up to it. The order is the other half of the idea. Halloween night usually means a room full of people with very different thresholds, so the list runs from a time-travel slasher comedy to the most punishing gore on the menu. Start at the top with the friend who hates jump scares, and keep going only as far as the whole room agrees to. The last two are for whoever is still on the couch after everyone else has gone home.
Totally Killer
Nahnatchka Khan's slasher comedy opens with a local legend: the Sweet Sixteen Killer murdered three girls on Halloween night in 1987. Thirty-five years later he strikes again, and teenage Jamie (Kiernan Shipka) escapes in her best friend's science-fair time machine, landing on that same Halloween in 1987, where her future mom (Olivia Holt) is the school's resident bully.
This is the gentlest step on the ladder. It plays like Carpenter's Halloween run through Back to the Future, so the kills come with punchlines and the eighties culture shock carries whole scenes. Put it on first for the friend who swears they don't do horror.
The Guest
A soldier named David (Dan Stevens) knocks on the Petersons' door, says he served in Afghanistan with their son who never came home, and is invited to stay. The whole town is biding its time until Halloween, and so is the guest. Adam Wingard directs from Simon Barrett's script, with Maika Monroe as the Petersons' daughter Anna.
Wingard named The Terminator and "an idealised synthy John Carpenter 80s wonderland where it's always Halloween" as his main influences, hence the pulsing soundtrack and the holiday hanging over every scene. More thriller than horror, with more swagger than gore, it belongs near the gentle end.
Trick 'r Treat
Four stories cross on one Halloween night in Michael Dougherty's anthology: a school principal hiding a dark secret, a college-bound girl looking for her date, a group of teenagers planning a prank, and a wife fed up with arguing. Anna Paquin and Brian Cox lead the cast, and a small trick-or-treater called Sam (Quinn Lord) keeps turning up between the stories.
No film here is more in love with the holiday itself. Dougherty treats Halloween as the main character and the four stories as its errands, which makes the scares feel playful even when they bite. Save it for when the room starts to warm up.
Tired of picking films by other people's ratings?
MyKinoList predicts your own. Start by rating a few films you've already seen.
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
The one Halloween sequel without Michael Myers. Producers John Carpenter and Debra Hill wanted to turn the series into a run of standalone Halloween stories, and Tommy Lee Wallace, editor and production designer on the original, took the director's chair. Tom Atkins plays a doctor who, with Stacey Nelkin, follows her father's murder to a small town ruled by Halloween-mask maker Conal Cochran (Dan O'Herlihy).
The whole film counts down to October 31, as children across the country wait to put those masks on. It is strange and cynical rather than gory, which makes it a sly middle step and the least expected title on the list.
Halloween
The plot fits on a postcard. Fifteen years after killing his sister on Halloween night, Michael Myers escapes and heads back to Haddonfield, Illinois, where Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis) is babysitting and his psychiatrist, Dr. Loomis (Donald Pleasence), is warning a town that isn't listening.
Carpenter builds his fear out of patience rather than blood, with slow tracking shots and a mask that never changes expression. That puts it right in the middle of the night: frightening enough for the horror veterans, restrained enough that the nervous half of the room can keep watching. Every other film on this list is in some way a reply to it.
Ginger Snaps
Ginger (Katharine Isabelle) and Brigitte (Emily Perkins) Fitzgerald stage mock suicides for school projects and have sworn to be dead or gone by sixteen. Then something in the woods bites Ginger, and her body starts changing on a schedule that lines up with her period and with the town's upcoming Halloween festivities. John Fawcett directs Karen Walton's sharp script, and Mimi Rogers is very funny as their mother.
From here the fear turns physical. The werewolf-as-puberty idea is impossible to miss, yet the real stake is the bond between the sisters, which gives the finale more weight than a creature feature usually earns.
Night of the Demons
Two outcasts, goth Angela (Amelia Kinkade) and her friend Suzanne (Linnea Quigley), throw a Halloween party in Hull House, an abandoned mortuary with a nasty past. A séance in front of a mirror wakes what lives beneath the building, and the guests start getting possessed one by one. Kevin Tenney directs from Joe Augustyn's script, with makeup effects by Steve Johnson.
It is the rowdiest film on the list and the most covered in holiday trimmings, from the animated opening credits to a bookend story about razor blades hidden in apples. Late-eighties camp keeps it fun, though the demon makeup marks a clear step up in nastiness.
Late Night with the Devil
It is Halloween night, 1977. Talk-show host Jack Delroy (David Dastmalchian) is losing in the ratings and about to lose his contract, so he bets everything on a live special whose star guest is a girl said to be possessed. Australian brothers Cameron and Colin Cairnes play the whole broadcast in real time, ad breaks included, cutting backstage in black and white during the breaks.
The format suits a party crowd, since it feels like a channel you stumbled onto at midnight. Once the show goes off the rails, though, the practical effects turn properly gruesome, and this is where the squeamish may start reaching for the remote.
Haunt
On Halloween night, Harper (Katie Stevens), fresh out of a bad relationship, heads out with her friends and finds an "extreme" haunted house that promises to feed on their darkest fears. The monsters inside turn out to be real. Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, the writers of A Quiet Place, wrote and directed it, with Eli Roth producing.
Here the list passes the point of no return. Anyone who has walked through a seasonal scare maze has laughed at the actors in masks, and Haunt builds its cruelty on exactly that trust. It is for the half of the room that wanted more after the possessed talk show.
Terrifier
Damien Leone's slasher has almost no plot, and that is the point. On Halloween night Art the Clown (David Howard Thornton) fixes on a group of young women, Jenna Kanell and Catherine Corcoran among them, and a creepy encounter in an abandoned building becomes a fight for survival.
Put it last, and only if everyone left in the room has said yes out loud. When the original got a wide theatrical run years after its debut, Leone's own pitch dared audiences to stomach Art's notorious hacksaw scene and told them to bring barf bags. That scene's reputation is exactly why the film closes the list rather than opening it.
Tired of picking films by other people's ratings?
MyKinoList predicts your own. Start by rating a few films you've already seen.
